Open Letter to my Child's Doctor |
Maria Trifonidis |
|
President of Floga, Greece |
Dear
doctor,
I
have a lot of things to tell you. I will make
the effort to bring you into line with me so that we can both see through
my eyes, the eyes of a parent, what it is that a parent expects from her child's
physician. It is an attempt to establish cooperation and mutual respect between
the physician and the parent, and to achieve the optimum result.
Many
thoughts ran through my mind before I wrote this letter:
-
Experiences,
not only my personal ones, but also those of so many other parents.
-
The necessity
for good cooperation amongst us and the possibility of rendering it
more efficient.
-
Understanding,
and the way that both parents and doctors can express it
-
Truth, and
how much can be expressed without creating any problems
-
Opposite
viewpoints and to what extent they overlap
-
Human
weaknesses and to what extent these can be surpassed.
-
First of all,
allow me to say a few words about us, the parents, who constitute the Parents'
Associations all over the world, who we are and what our wishes and expectations
are.
We
are not anybody special or particular. We are ordinary people, facing everyday
life and,until yesterday, we considered the presence of our children an
undisputable fact.
And
suddenly, clouds darken our blue skies. As simply as that. One day; one morning.
The whole of our life and everything that we were trying to build and establish
up to that moment is turned upside down within a single moment, without warning,
without reason or any cause. We are suddenly confronted with an unbelievable
fact: our child suffers from cancer !
Resentment
is succeeded by anger and anger by scruples - a chain of sentiments to be
endured by all parents under these circumstances. For how long will resentment,
anger and scruples prevail? This depends on many factors. These factors are
ourselves, our character and age, our education and culture, our surroundings,
our friends and above all, our doctors. But we must endure, and so we do.
All
of a sudden, from one moment to the next, irrespective of the level of education
of any of us, we have to learn what, in fact, cancer means
when a child is affected, which medical
institutions cope with it, the therapeutic options that exist in Greece and
abroad, of what chemotherapy consists and what the side effects are, what it
means for the patient to have low white blood cells and blood platelets, what
the therapy protocols mean and a large number of other things.
In
contrast to you, dear doctor, who chose and prepared yourself to become a doctor
and the physician of my child, I, personally, was neither asked nor have I ever
chosen or ever intended to step into your office for consultation under these
circumstances.
The
endeavors intended for our children
First
and foremost, we are concerned to have doctors with a sound professional
training and specialization in this field to look after our children, because,
prior to securing quality of life,
we are concerned with life itself for our children. We request that the State
establish measures for a continuous post-graduate training for doctors, but also
of an evaluation of their capability. We also request specialization studies in
the field of oncology, the registration of cancer cases in children, the
treatment protocols, the final outcome etc.
The
life and death of our child is our main concern and obligation, and, therefore,
we believe that it lies within our responsibilities and rights to address any
action which concerns and is directed at the child's life, to whatever authority
and in whatever direction.
Prompt
diagnosis means prevention of cancer
Allow
me to refer first of all to the general pediatric practitioner, as I consider
him to be the first and basic factor which may lead to the final cure of our
children, because it is from him that we expect a prompt diagnosis, or at least
the prompt referral to hospital.
At
this point, I wish to mention my personal experience, because I still believe
that if my daughter's pediatrician had listened attentively and had looked into
my concerns and investigated the matter, if he had been properly informed, if
some public factor had obliged him to present himself in hospitals now and then,
if he had come across a similar case in his career, then possibly the diagnosis
might have been made in due time and maybe, Alexandra would be here with us
today. Symptoms were more than obvious (as was ascertained afterwards) and yet
he still did not understand precisely what the matter was and, what is more, he
stopped us from going to hospital.
Mention
of this specific case is not being made just to reopen old wounds.
I
wish that these cases constituted the minority, but - alas - it is not so.
Children's lives are lost because their pediatrician is not in a position to
understand the cause promptly and because he refuses to listen to the anxieties
of the parents, rejecting them before examining them.
The
mother's instinct should be followed. It will lead you the correct way. Listen
attentively to what she has to say. Changes in the child's behavior lead the
mothers to you and you, in turn, should look into the matter and weigh up the
anxieties.
The
whole responsibility for a prompt diagnosis lies with the general pediatric
practitioner. The pediatrician must have the required knowledge and experience
in order to gain time: time to start treatment promptly and consequently to have
the best possible result. We have been told that pediatricians, while practicing
for their special areas, visit and practice in all the departments of children's
hospitals, except in the oncology wards, because there is no such special area.
But, since there is no such special area, how come there is a department in
hospitals? Since, then, there is a department and children with neoplasia are
hospitalized there, that means that a pediatrician will not have the opportunity
to encounter such a sick child and, therefore, he will not have dealt with a
child suffering from cancer during the whole period of his practice, the only
chance of his coming across a case of cancer is in the hospital's out-patient
department, where, however, the special oncologist pediatrician will be called.
The result, therefore, is a child with cancer visiting his practice and the
doctor, not having acquired previous pertinent experience and knowledge, often
cannot make a prompt diagnosis.
Pediatric
Oncologist
My
dear doctor, as of today, the diagnosis concerning my child having been made,
you will have a permanent place in my life and in my thoughts and your name will
often be referred to in my home. We have become acquainted under circumstances
so very pressing and unpleasant. However, we are meant to proceed to a
relationship based on a common endeavor and cause. My wish is to proceed with
all our strength, each of us from a different position and with a different
role, in order to succeed in our common purpose - the best medical care possible
and final cure, the assurance of quality of life during the time of therapy and
the appropriate integration of the child in its social surroundings.
Before
proceeding to an analysis of all the things I expect from you, I will ask for
your understanding and I will try to make you see why I ask for so many things.
I have huge expectations from you, because your job, your profession, deals with
the life and death of my child. There is no way back, there is no room for
amendments, asking to be excused because of an excessive workload cannot be
accepted, mentioning that not enough attention has been given or it has escaped
the doctor's notice and therefore, a mistake has been made, cannot be accepted.
Our children do not come back. Children are not accounting books to be corrected
later on, they are not a lesson with mistakes in the classroom, which can be
corrected the following day, they are not a wrong purchase, which can be
revoked.
My
wishes concerning you
As
long as my child is under your care, I am very much interested in and concerned
for your well-being in general, both as a doctor and a person. It really is my
sincerest wish that you be happy at home and that you enjoy complete personal
and family peace and stability. In this way, you will be able to develop all
your capabilities and sensitiveness and dedicate all the attention needed to the
field of your professional career, the successful course of which is directly
connected with the biological and psychological healing of my child and its
natural integration in the social surroundings.
If
need be, you may bring home - your home - my "case" but not my
"problem". Every time a child is lost, I really wish that you will not
suffer, but that you will increase your efforts to improve your knowledge to
acquire better results. So that your mind may remain open and clear, you must
protect yourself from the pressure
of your work and failures.
Meeting
for the first time
When
we first meet, do not be abrupt, do not expect me to easily accept everything
you have to say to me. You should not put me off with an austere, cold and
brusque briefing, leaving out any hope. At that moment, you are the fellow
person, perhaps you are a parent, please be polite and patient, please respect
the tempest that has suddenly befallen my life. From now on we will,
unfortunately, meet frequently and daily, so you can tell me what is required.
Please, allow time for me to weigh up and recover my strength, to find weapons
and defences, to stay upright at my child's side.
You
yourself may have seen many parents in this same situation and the briefing of
new parents may have become a routine matter for you, but, please, do not forget
that it is the first day for me, the first briefing for me and that it concerns
the life and the death of my child.
Allow
me room to stand, because suddenly my own life acquires a particular value,
since now I am obliged to live, for I have to offer my assistance to my child.
Dear
doctor, please consider that until yesterday I did not know you, I did not even
know what a neoplastic disease meant for children. Until yesterday I did not
even know that cancer also affects children.
My
mind perceived the "abominable" disease and the unavoidable and awful
end of life associated with it. Mostly through television channels and
newspapers, people learn to mistrust public hospitals. At the time I was being
informed, as a first step and for the first time, my mind went back to
everything that I ever had come across concerning negligence and errors on the
part of doctors, delays, camp beds filling the corridors, miracles happening
abroad and many other things, all of which make me feel insecure and mistrustful
towards you and the public hospitals represented by you.
I
find myself in a whirlwind, which, if it does not calm down, will not allow me
to understand the changes it has brought to my life and let me concentrate and
tidy up the ruins left behind.
What
I expect from you
My
wish is first and foremost that you may set aside any selfish sentiments and
that in a spirit of goodwill, you may cooperate and unite forces with your
colleagues and attain the best possible results for my child. My wish is that
your colleagues be your cooperators and not your rivals. I wish that you may all
hold frequent conferences concerning the therapy protocols and their outcomes.
If your views do not coincide, you should, please, consult other doctors in
Greece or abroad and check your doubts and fears. Please send the specialized
centres a few tests which may prompt queries, and seek a second opinion.
Do
on your own initiative whatever the State does not compel you to do. Always be
in a state of continuous awareness, revise your knowledge, update the therapy
methods, try to steadily improve the nursing conditions, be permanently at the
centre of medical development in your field.
Accept
the possibility of your being mistaken, admit your possible error in time and
don't be selfish, but take corrective action immediately.
Please
help me with your behavior to be acquainted with you, to know you, to evaluate
your personality and feel secure leaving my child's destiny in your hands.
Please, be accessible, friendly and modest so that I may feel at ease and ask
you again and again about something I did not understand or
do not want to understand.
My
wish is to be treated equally. Whoever I happen to be, a minister or a worker, I
am entitled to and wish my child to have equal opportunities to recover and have
the same attention.
Please
be kind enough to understand my insecurities, to accept my doubts and not be
annoyed when I want to have a
second opinion about my child's condition and prospects. If I have been told of
a colleague in your field in Greece or abroad, who I think can be of help, do
not consider it humiliating - let me ask for his opinion. If I consider that it
is to my child's advantage to be taken care of in another hospital, be it either
the one next door or in another country, please hand me my child's file and let
me go. I can use my discretion to choose my child's doctor and I have the right
to do so. If, somewhere, there is a better prospect, an additional hope, you,
dear doctor, ought to inform me and assist me in chasing it up. It is
fundamental for me, extremely fundamental, to rest assured that I did everything
possible for the sake of my child.
Please,
think thoroughly before talking to me and be sure about what you have to say.
Tell me about your "ascertainments". Your fears and anxieties should
be investigated, discussed with your own self and with your cooperators.
Please,
it is my wish that I should be listened to attentively. I want to trust my
parent's intuition and to have my remarks with regard to my child taken
seriously, because they may lead you to useful conclusions for the course of the
disease.
Please,
talk to me patiently, plainly and clearly, in accordance with my perception and
capabilities. Each one of us parents is a unique individual with different
capabilities, intellect and education.
Since
you are a member of a team, my wish is that you operate as a team and that you
discuss your doubts within the team and not with me. My wish is to hear a
justified view from you, the result of cooperation amongst you all.
Your
professional training is of most importance to me, but this alone is not enough
for me. My wish is that, through your friendly and pleasant behavior and your
assurances, you may be able to convince the child itself to feel secure and to
accept the fact that all the painful treatment and medical tests are temporary
and should be carried out for its own good.
Please,
pay attention to the child during the final stage, and the child's family.
Continue to strive till the last moment. My wish is that you may remember that
everything you say is of particular importance both for the parent and the child
listening to you. Before starting to talk, think carefully about what you going
to say. Pressure on the family is terrific and balances are particularly
fragile.
Please,
keep in touch with the children who have been healed, be interested in the
course of their health, discuss with them their anxieties and fears and answer
their questions.
Please
do understand that you are a professional, caring for health and I am a parent
striving for my child. We are engaged in the same fight but in different roles.
My wish is that you respect the autonomy of the Parents' Associations, that you
may always be in touch, cooperating with them, for the development of a real
coalition to the advantage of all children.
Epilogue
My
family and myself have been deprived of the presence of our Alexandra for 18
years. Circumstances have obliged us to live these 18 years without her. Now,
after such a long time, we have realized that even those six years she was with
us were enough to fill us with experiences and memories for a whole life. The
two years we fought to keep her with us, were transformed into the most
significant part of our life. For two years, we travelled from hope to
disappointment and from heaven to earth. We filled our
hands and hearts, we offered our worship and enriched our life with
sentiments never before felt and utterly moving. We were given the opportunity
to stay by the side of this child, who, like all the other children of "Floga"
developed unbelievable powers, surpassing human nature and teaching all of us
who happened to be next to her, what is the meaning of love, strength,
self-respect, decency and courage.
A
glimpse of life, so brief, yet so intense, a glimpse so tiny, yet so sturdy. A
glimpse of an existence never having faltered in our home, because the doors of
our souls have been kept wide open, as our embracing arms offered hospitality,
with room for all those children fighting their battle, the same battle with the
same passion and the same decency.
Dear
Doctor,
At
this precise period of our life, and regardless of whether we were able to keep
our children with us or not, your presence is of foremost significance and most
decisive. In all the years to come, you will have a place in our mind and in our
everyday life, having found yourself involved in our child's journey and having
been related to our child's destiny.
Let
these memories be good !
Let
us be proud of the presence of our child in our lives and let us remember dearly
your passage in our child's life!
Let
us be allowed to mourn the passing away of our child, without scruples and
doubts for our decisions. Extend to our soul peace and assurance and you will
have our love and respect.
It depends on you.
Maria
Trifonidis
President
of Floga